What if we are all just characters in a story? What if the fact that I wrote this and that you are reading this is something that was plotted by some unknown author? This means whatever you’re thinking right now is just according to a script. All your thoughts, emotions, knowledge, habits and experiences are all fabricated by the one who holds the pen (or keyboard).
I know this is a hard sell. It is because making it work needs some imagination and broadness of mind. So if you think it’s impossible or not plausible, it’s ok. Limits are understandable. Maybe that was your characterization. Maybe that’s how you were made (or written): A bit special.
Well, this is not my original idea. I encountered this while reading “Sophie’s World.” And I’m sure that some of you have thought of this possibility. I really find the concept curious. The idea that we are just fictions of someone’s mind – it’s surreal. The solid earth that you were once standing on becomes a flimsy paper with printed letters. It could also be annoying to think that we are all just characters in some cheap soap opera or B movie. Or, that we are all just playing second string to some main protagonist we don’t even know who. Maybe it’s me; maybe it’s you. But whatever the case, the idea that you’re not the main character of at least even your own life is a tenfold slap on the face of your ego. If you relate it to LOTR, you’re just a Gondor soldier in the melee that trips and gets trampled on by Orcs and Men, then flattened by an Oliphaunt. You didn’t even get to see, much less hold, The One Ring. You’re not even a character. You’re reduced to a mere background element.
If you still can’t grasp it, try the movies. If you’ve seen “Vanilla Sky,” you should get the drift. If you still can’t, then think of “The Matrix.” They all point to some alternate reality. Maybe the more accurate description is it’s the “real” world, versus the “dream” world. Although “The Matrix” did maintain the autonomy of human will and emotions, it doesn’t change the idea that much of their “normal” world was fabricated. And in this case, you don’t have a “real” world.
So, if we assume that our world is just in the head of some writer or printed ink on paper, what does that mean for us? It has a lot of impact on free will and deliberate actions. I can smack you on the head right now and tell you it’s all part of the script. Then you would smack me right back and tell me it’s also part of the script. It creates a comedic situation. You are not your own person anymore. Rather, you were never a person to begin with. It makes the entire world funny and amusing in a twisted and disturbed way.
All the things that we care about, love, hate, adore, and resent are all just given to us. And we had no choice about it. I guess, we would rebel then. But what if this rebellious feeling is also something designed for us; some form of literary device to move the story along? Isn’t that insulting? You’re just a means to an end. That’s the meaning of your existence.
If you push the idea some more, you’ll find yourself in a wonderful trap. And there’s nothing that you can do about it. Not even Houdini can’t escape from it. And once you’re written down, not even God can save you. The finality of the written word is absolute.
Is there a bright side to this? Of course there is. If we’re all just made up by some person, then that makes this life easier to understand. Not necessarily easier to accept, but comprehension is the first step to resignation (or acceptance, I like it negative). And what could be the best thing about this is you have somebody to blame. If this world is messed up, you have someone to direct your resentment at. Now, that’s a big thing. It gives you at least some peace of mind. And for some, a reason for existence: Something to hate. Of course, you can take this the positive way. You also have someone to be grateful to, someone to worship. If you were written like a James Bond or Tomb Raider character, then you have a lot to be thankful for. If you were written as the Queen Bee, or Silverback Gorilla, then you’ve got it good. At the lowest level of gratefulness, you can be thankful that you existed at all. That out of nothing you became something of some sort.
This can also engender a form of vengeance. That is, if you were allowed by the script to do so. You can start holding a pen yourself and start tormenting your own poor creations just for spite. Since you can’t reach the object of your revenge, you’re left to create some of your own. It can be quite sick once you think about it. But also consider how you can be sane when you’re given a concept of freedom but also exiled from it at the same time. You know what a free person is, only you’re not it. If that don’t get you gritting your teeth, then I give up.
Of course this is just a thought experiment. The eerie thing is, what if it was true?